Complete the Report if you have agreed to evaluate an applicant for an NSERC Postgraduate Scholarship-Doctoral (PGS D) or Postdoctoral Fellowship (PDF). The Report cannot be completed by a proposed supervisor unless that person is, or has been, the applicant's supervisor.
Refer to the Frequently Asked Questions for References Completing a Report on the Applicant – Form 201 for more information.
By submitting your Report to NSERC, you confirm that you have read and understood these instructions. This is in addition to the acceptance of the Terms and Conditions for References. Refer to the Signatures section.
It is important that the reference process be free of any bias, whether these biases are based on a school of thought, fundamental versus applied research, certain sub-disciplines, areas of research or approaches (including emerging ones), size or reputation of an institution, age, personal factors or the gender of the applicant. NSERC cautions references against any judgment of an application based on such factors and asks them to constantly guard against the possibility of unconscious bias influencing the decision-making process.
NSERC is actively engaged in increasing gender equity in its review processes to contribute to improved gender equality in science and engineering fields. For reference, see NSERC’s Policy Statement on Gender Equality in Science and Engineering and available resources such as Strengthening Canada’s Research Capacity: The Gender Dimension.
The collection, use and disclosure of personal information provided to NSERC is outlined in the following policy statements:
The information you provide in your Report is collected under the authority of the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council Act. NSERC is subject to the Access to Information Act and the Privacy Act. The information you provide is stored in a series of NSERC data banks described in Info Source Publications.
NSERC routinely gives applicants access to information about themselves that is kept in Council files, but does not provide the applicant with the name of the person who submitted the evaluation or the names of any other applicants mentioned in a comparative context. However, due to the nature of the application process, applicants are usually aware of who has completed their evaluation. As a result, you cannot expect privacy or anonymity.
Applicants will indicate in their application for a PGS D or PDF the name and email address of the two references who will complete the Report. An email will be generated by the On-line System inviting you, as a reference, to complete the Report. Follow the instructions in the email to provide your contact information and your assessment of the applicant. Complete and submit this information by the date specified by the applicant. You will also have access to the application submitted by the applicant.
Note: Applicants have been advised to provide their references with a deadline that is well before the application deadline, to allow applicants to submit their completed application on time. NSERC will not consider the application as complete without your Report.
Length of report
It is imperative that you preview your Report before it is submitted to ensure that the text fits within the available space, as the system will not stop you from going over the space limit. Text that is not visible on the previewed Report will not be seen by NSERC staff or the selection committee members.
Once the Report is completed, follow instructions to submit it electronically. The applicant will be advised that the Report was completed but will not be able to view its content (refer to the Personal Information section). Once the Report is submitted, you will no longer have access to it. If you wish to make changes, you must communicate with the applicant and request that the Report be “unlocked” for revisions. Once the Report is unlocked, you will be able to make the changes and resubmit the Report electronically. Once the applicant has submitted the full application to NSERC, this functionality will no longer be available.
If you are completing an evaluation
Comment on each evaluation criterion listed below, and provide a justification of your evaluation. Rather than providing general comments, assess the applicant's strengths and limitations for each criterion. Include examples of the applicant's accomplishments and contributions to support your assessment.
Research ability or potential
Communication, interpersonal, and leadership abilities
|Relative weighting of criteria|
|Research ability or potential||50||70|
|Communication, interpersonal, and leadership abilities||20||30|
NSERC does not require original signatures on applications or other documents submitted electronically through its On-line System. The electronic submission of applications through this system represents approval and replaces the traditional "physical" or "wet" signatures.
Before you, as a reference, can submit the Report to NSERC, you must read and agree to the Terms and Conditions for References that are found at the end of the submission process. It is your responsibility to retain a copy of the agreed Terms and Conditions for your records.